
After watching Gautham Menon ‘s Vaarnam Ayiram, I can say for sure that he is the best modern tamil movie director after Mani Ratnam.
But in what?
I would say in portraying suavity & slickness in a movie.
What about screenplay, spontaneity or a good story-line? Sorry Mr. Menon, there are better ones than you.
This is not a spoiler of the movie, so guys relax.
Imagine Madhavan in the C rated movie “Arya” and in Alaipayuthey. People would easily know which performance was a chalk and which one was a cheese. As many know an actor is as good as his director. GM brings out the best of Surya in this movie. No doubt about that.
The refreshing part is that the story is not a liftoff from any English movies (forget Forrest Gump) and is quite natural without too much complications.
Things I liked:
The bespectacled father with a unique & dignified demeanor. A pleasure to watch. Simran pulls out a cracker of a performance.
The songs & cinematography. It is difficult to match good songs with better visuals. Ask Bharathiraja about spoiling good A.R. Rahman songs. But GM is mind blowing here.
Be it Taj or San Francisco or
5 stars for Surya’s emotions, six-packs and aviator glasses.
Sameera Reddy’ smile, her deglamorised approach and her sensible romance with Surya.
Cute Divya and her saree.
Mundinam Parthene song. Painstakingly GM had constructed vintage sets to give it a 70’s touch.
The subtle touches in the screenplay which are very original.
The downside:
Narration style is pathetic. God sake GM could have avoided this.
The English dialogues which were supposed to increase the “coolness” of the film didn’t serve the purpose at all and would alienate rural movie goers.
Length of the movie. Certainly the army heroics and the bravery stunts could have been cut down.
All in all a good movie.
But brace yourself for 3 hrs as it certainly isn’t a classic and can get you the occasional yawn.
... and appa I love you